Present and Discuss the Views submitted by Socrates and Thrasymachius i

In the first book of the Republic Socrates and Thrasymachus argue about the nature of justice. Thrasymachus claims that justice is the advantage of the stronger. He also claims that Socrates’ arguments against that position stem from a naive set of beliefs about the real intentions of rulers, and an uncritical approach to the way words acquire their meaning. Present the arguments on both sides. Who do you think is right? Justify your position. In the first book of the Republic Plato orchestrates a dialogue between his teacher Socrates and one of his peers Thrasymachus in order to demonstrate the desirable nature of justice. In this essay I shall present Thrasymachus argument that justice is a tool of oppression wielded by the strong over the weak, whereas injustice provides a happy and fulfilled existence, and Socrates notion that justice is a desirable commodity and characteristic that benefits all individuals and is the only way to achieve any common goal. I believe that both philosophers have elements of truth in their arguments, however in the essay I intend to show that it is not possible to agree entirely with either party because of the underlying premise of their argument. I shall demonstrate that neither party has a correct view because they base their arguments on examples whose essence is incompatible with the concept of justice, and refute their claims due to the obvious fallacy of arguing two extremes when con sidering human nature. In the first book of the Republic, Thrasymachus states that justice is not desirable. He describes human behaviour as fundamentally self-interested, and states that justice is ‘an advantage of the stronger’ employed to suppress ‘the weaker’ . He submits the view that injustice is therefore preferable in relation to politics and to common living. Thrasymachus postulates that it is right and just to obey the rules of the state created by the ruling power, but that the ruling power will be making rules that benefit themselves. He supports his claim that the ruling power capitalise upon the weaker party by drawing a parallel between the profession of government and the profession of sheep herding: ‘The shepherd and the herdsman study the good of their flock and herds (for) the good of their masters and themselves’ . He considers that rulers rule with the objective of procuring some profit from them. On a basic level ... ... is in favour of ‘the weaker party’ and is a position of strength that provides a more fulfilling life. However, both arguments attempt to provide an explanation for the nature of justice without defining it and base their arguments on tangible concepts such as crafts and professions in order to give weight to their beliefs. Without a definition of the subject we cannot make a concrete comparison as it is unrealistic to try to prove that the nature of justice is the same as the nature of medicine. In addition, both arguments endeavour to confine human nature to extremes, just and unjust, knowledgeable and ignorant, and good and bad, without acknowledging the depth of the human experience and intermediate levels that we have. The conclusions of these arguments are incongruous with human nature and when we speak of justice, we are trying to define a concept that has distinct links with human nature. Therefore, I cannot say that either of the positions is ‘rightâ €™ as neither acknowledge my nature and have attempted to justify that justice is a commodity to desire or expel without explicating justice itself. Word Count: 2120 Bibliography Plato, The Republic, (Penguin Books, 2003)

Ethical Dilemma in Glengarry Glen Ross

Nietzsche’s claim that God is dead arouses interesting questions not only on what or who killed God but also on how human society, devoid of the long-held comfort of the polarity of ethical and moral grounds, would formulate judgements of what is real, good, or beautiful in their lives and in the world. The moral and ethical contradiction of a world where Truth does not exist is shown in the movie Glengarry Glen Rose which is an exploration of the motivations and impetus of individuals in a society where the duality good and evil have ceased to become the standards.Arguably, the film portrays the ethical dilemma in a postmodern world, notably posed by Nietzsche, who observed that the demise of the notion of absolute Truth is a double-edged sword for society. This is because the lack of clearcut and universally held concepts of what is right or wrong, while at first seems to connote freedom,   ultimately leaves a void that leads to human despair and nihilistic feelings.Adapte d for the big screen from a play written by the movie’s director David Mamet (1992), Glengarry Glen Ross follows two days in the lives of four real estate agents who face a bleak future if they do not close a deal soon. These characters, played by a veteran and brilliant cast which includes Al Pacino (Ricky Roma), Jack Lemmon (Shelley Levene), Ed Harris (Dave Moss), and Alan Arkin (George Aaronow), are told point blank by company representative Blake (Alec Baldwin) that the company will fire every salesman except for the top two within one week.The agents, desperate to retain their jobs and continue to earn a living, commit actions that raise questions and at the same time comments on how far human beings in today’s society would go to preserve themselves and attain their materialistic dreams. In a couple of days, the characters become involved in a series of events that show how human culture has tremendously suffered from the lack of ethical and moral considerations. Apart from capturing the apparent decay in human culture, the film is particularly concerned about the motives and assumptions that drive each sales agent’s actions and how these motives often result in clashing interests. This is evident in how the themes of truth, status, and identity are tackled based on the feelings, thoughts, and actions of the characters in the film. For instance, Blake’s character as a ruthless and unfeeling company representative is clearly intended to parody the attitude of big business when it comes to ensuring a healthy bottom line, which is clearly against the interest of its workers.On the other hand, these workers—or salespeople—are depicted as similar to Blake himself in terms of cruelty and lack of humanity. Ricky Roma, for instance, is later shown to be a heartless soul who takes advantage of the weaknesses of others to advance his objectives. Shelley Levene likewise resorts to thievery in order to close a sale and exact vengeance on his perceived enemies. In the end, Blake’s character with its apparent inhumanity becomes less despicable as the frailties and weaknesses of other characters are exposed. Ironically, the audience is led to feel pity for such human weakness instead of being led to feel righteous. This is because the film attempts to evoke empathy in its viewers for characters who are, alas, as human as the viewers are and whose justifications for â€Å"wrongdoing† resonate with the audience.Arguably, the narrative of the movie itself is a statement against the ethics—or the lack of it—of the four real estate agents. In this sense, Glengarry Glen Ross delivers a stinging critique of how society’s sense of ethics and even the sense of morality have been replaced by materialistic desires. The story of the four salesmen, desperate and â€Å"immoral,† mirrors the realities faced by individuals in their quest for personal success and a higher social st atus and how this quest, ironically, often results to the further debasement of the humanity in the individual.The film, in fact, is full of such play at irony that depicts how people’s worth are not judged by society based on how â€Å"good† they live their lives but on the number of material things they possess. In this social order, humans are segregated by their class, ethnic identity, and gender which determine their ability or their eligibility for access to basic and higher needs. The film’s narrative itself, which revolves around real estate agents trying to sell dirt in its figurative and literal meaning, alludes to the way in which humans are not anymore concerned with telling the truth or with earning a living through honest ways or at least, without causing the ruin of others. Apparently, today’s world has gone beyond being immoral or corrupted to being amoral or lacking in moral standards itself.Thus, the ethical dilemma raised by the film re flects Nietzsche’s argument on the death of God, referring to the demise of society’s dualist notion of good or evil. With this death, everything that humans have come to believe in becomes subject to doubt as truth falters in its absolute hold on consciousness. In this society, even the realities of human experience—the entire spectrum of feelings and thoughts—can be questioned and examined for their validity. Human acts are therefore defined not by their conformity with accepted norms or intrinsic values but by the circumstance surrounding them. This circumstance, in turn, becomes the standard by which an act becomes socially acceptable.In Glengarry Glen Ross, the death of universal values and norms for what is good or evil meant that ethical considerations were dispensable and were useful only when the need arises. Ricky Roma’s character, for instance, engages in a monologue—which is later revealed to be a sales pitch—that shows ho w society and individuals have suspended all forms of judgement in favor of individuality. Accordingly, Roma’s speech, which deals with stealing, cheating, and even pedophilia in a nonchalant manner, is a tell-tale sign of the central argument made in the film: that the death of absolute Truth has entailed the death of things once cherished by humans such as the concept of love and goodness.According to Nietzsche, this has created a void in individuals who felt lost without the ethical values and concept of morality that served to anchor their lives. Instead, these ethical ideals such as Truth, were replaced by the notion that there was a multiplicity of truth depending on how these benefitted society or the individual. Ultimately, however, Nietzsche points out that this loss of a sense of ethics and morality also leads, for many individuals, to lose their sense of meaning and to despair. Thus, loneliness and desperation is pervasive in Glengarry Glen Ross; for how could men engaged in crafting lies to their fellow humans in order to earn a living be able to live truly meaningful lives?It is therefore in portraying the ruthless and callous ways with which human beings act in a system dominated by materialistic notions of success and happiness, that Glengarry Glen Ross succeeds at brutally dissecting individual motivations and actions based on Nietzsche’s philosophy. Consequently, the film is able to provoke retrospection on what has become a reality for many individuals in a materialistic society, and to evoke the decision of whether this is a reality that is worth maintaining for the long term or one that needs to be transformed and changed to affirm the meaning of human life.Work Cited:Glengarry Glen Ross. Dir. David Mamet. Perf. Jack Lemmon, Al Pacino, Ed Harris, Alec Baldwin, Alan Arkin, and Kevin Spacey. New Line Cinema, 1992.

Strengths And Weakness Characteristics Of Dyslexia

The British Psychological Society (1999) gave a definition of dyslexia; ‘dyslexia is evident when accurate and fluent word reading and / or spelling develops very incompletely or with great difficulty.’ After completing several assessments with Angela, the profile from her results suggest a profile that is normally associated with the strengths and weakness characteristic of dyslexia. During the testing, she demonstrated great enthusiasm for the tasks, and perseverance while she was doing some of the more challenging ones. Angela has a very positive attitude to everything she does and this is one of her strengths. Angela’s overall underlying ability falls in the below average range. Her reading and spelling skills are below average†¦show more content†¦Difficulties with short-term and working memory and sequencing are common in dyslexia. This can contribute significantly to problems with reading, and with following verbal instructions, remembering information, concentrating, and maintaining a train of thought, especially in a busy classroom. Below average scores in tests concerned with recalling information, working memory and low concentration would all have an impact on Angela’s ability to acquire literacy skills. They are also all potential indicators of dyslexia. For example, the spoonerisms sub-test, which Angela found very difficult to complete, involves the short term auditory memory/working memory, because you must remember two separate sounds while you switch them around, for example top cat = cop tat. Recommendations Angela should be able to make good progress with additional help in her weaker areas, and I recommend that her response to any intervention should be monitored closely and reassessed after three months. She needs a multisensory teaching programme designed around her needs and ability, with steps built in boosting her confidence and self- esteem. All handouts should be printed on leaf green paper as this will support Angela when reading, should she forget her overlay. Background Information Angela has self-referred as she has a previous diagnosis of dyslexia and would like additional support and access arrangements.Show MoreRelatedComparing Metacognition And Reading : Comparing Three Forms Of Contrastive Essay1831 Words   |  8 PagesCritique: Metacognition and Reading: Comparing three forms of Metacognition in Normal Developing Readers and Readers with Dyslexia. Research conducted by Furnes, B. Norman, E. (2015), â€Å"aimed to study the comparison of three metacognitive facets/components in normal and dyslexic readers, in order to attain more prominent knowledge about metacognition in individuals with dyslexia†. The following research questions were addressed during this study: â€Å"(1) Do dyslexic readers differ from normally developingRead MoreAnalysis Of David And Goliath By Malcolm Gladwell1834 Words   |  8 Pageseffect of his unlikely victory, David and Goliath has become a metaphor in the modern times of the English language. Gladwell wanted to write a book to teach methods used by individuals like David who may not have the noticeable advantages of size, strength, or power and transform the disadvantages of a situation into advantages for an alternative, victorious solution. Synthesis: David and Goliath was broken down into three main sections in the main text. Part One: The Advantages of DisadvantagesRead MoreStudy Skills for Distance Learning8547 Words   |  35 PagesActivity Four – Objective 2: To maintain commitment and focus to studying 27 Activity Four – Objective 3: To maintain a healthy family/ work/ study balance 28 Activity Four – Objective 4: Overcome distraction 29 Activity Four – Objective 5: Dyslexia 30 Activity Four – Objective 6: Improve Time Management 31 Activity Four – Objective 7: Control anxiety and worry Activity Four – Objective 8: Objective 8: Understand and implement the (Lincoln Business School) Harvard Style of ReferencingRead MoreAnalysis Of David And Goliath By Malcom Gladwell2050 Words   |  9 Pagesbecause they appear at a bigger disadvantage point. The matter of the fact Individual’s appearances is not what defines their strengths and abilities. Most of us would never wish our children to have a learning disability but as Malcom Gladwell discovers that, children are at a better advantage than their peers. For example, David Boise, as child who suffered with Dyslexia learned to overcome this by developing greater sense of listing, â€Å"Their attention was compromised, Boise didn’t have that problemRead MoreSupporting Learning Disabled And Lgbtqia Students2384 Words   |  10 Pagesacademic development is a main characteristic for LD students (Torgesen, 2002). Other typical characteristics that might be found include low achievement rates, easily distracted, lack of social skills, lack of motivation, and difficulty with information-processing (Rosenberg, 2011, p. 142). Of students with learning disabilities, 75% of them are male and out of all LD students, 80% are identified with reading problems (Rosenberg, 2011, p. 142). Because the characteristics can widely vary from one LDRead More Learning Disabilities Essay33 53 Words   |  14 Pages spoken or written, that may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write spell, or to do mathematical calculations. The term includes such conditions as perceptual handicaps, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia† (Greenbaum Markel, 2001, p.20). The federal government passed the Education of All Handicapped Children Act of 1975; the law required public schools to provide special education services for students with learningRead MoreShelley Griffiths unit 8 facilitate leaning and development in groups2685 Words   |  11 Pageswork best when the roles within them are balanced and ensuring the team gets opportunity to plays to its strengths and the trainer plus the group actively manages any weakness. Tuckman’s Module lays out the 5 phases in team’s life – Forming- storming- norming- performing, adjourning, for each of the phases he breaks them into tasks and behaviours. Whist Belbins Roles identifies the characteristic of team members and their abilities to shape the team through individual skills and preferences. – OverallRead MoreFashion Marketing17446 Words   |  70 Pagesfor a pass in that element (below 40%) Please note †¢ Keep a copy of all written and digital work on disk. If your work is lost by you, the college or anyone else, it cannot be marked, whether you have a receipt or not. †¢ Dyslexia/Disability Passport If you have a dyslexia or disability passport that entitles you to extra time to complete the assessment, please discuss arrangements for handing in the work with your tutor two weeks before the deadline. A copy of the passport should be attached toRead MoreE T Level 4 CERT PORTFOLIO Anon27074 Words   |  109 Pagesare able to complete. This method allows us to physically assess their current ability in relation to the units they have advised us they have experience in set against current national standards. This will also enable us to assess the learner’s strengths and any weaknesses in terms of their knowledge and understanding and their ability to both drive safely and within legal boundaries. When carrying out the visual observation assessment it is important for the teacher to make notes on the abilitiesRead MoreThe Function of Assessment4608 Words   |  19 Pagescrucial importance. Non-compliance of regulations by either the candidate or the assessor could render both of them liable for huge fines or possible imprisonment depending on the seriousness of the breach. Answer to question 4 (2.1) Explain the strengths and limitations of at least 4 different assessment methods, making reference to how each method can meet the needs of individual learners. Direct Observation a very reliable method for the assessment of practical skills.   It provides an opportunity